Home « 

What is the Best High Risk Auto Insurance With an Online Quote?

A black Dodge Challenger driving down a road on an Autumn day.
This post may contain affiliate links from the Amazon Associate program.
Spread the love
Reading Time: 5 minutes

Are you surprised that your insurance company has listed you as a “high-risk” driver? Well, to avoid any insurance-related surprises, you must learn how insurance companies categorize drivers and how each category affects your premiums. You also need to identify the best high-risk auto insurance on the market. You’re in luck because we cover all this in the article below.

What Does It Mean to Be a “High-Risk’ Driver?

A “high-risk” driver is an individual who is likely to file a claim. Insurers consider several factors before they categorize someone as a “high-risk” driver. Some common factors include:

  • Number of accidents within the last three years
  • Credit history
  • Speeding tickets and traffic-related citations
  • When you received your driver’s license
  • A DWI or DUI 
  • The value of owning a sports car 
  • A requirement by the state to file an SR-22 or FR-44
  • Where you live

While the insurance rates may seem too high for you, the insurer usually believes you contribute to the highest amount of expenditure. If you find yourself on the “high-risk” driver list and want to consider the best high-risk auto insurance, here are options you can choose from.

The General

The General is a low-cost, “high-risk” auto insurance company that allows “high-risk” drivers to get insurance policies, including those convicted for driving under the influence. The company insures just about everyone and provides low down payment options.

According to rating agency AM Best, The General has one of the best financial “strengths.” Should you file a claim, the company can quickly pay out the claim. The General provides coverage in most states except Michigan, New Jersey, and Massachusetts.

The company lets you handle everything by yourself, from the quote process to filing the claim. You can either fill your claim through their website, smartphone app, or phone call. 

Average Annual Premium

The following average annual premiums are for a:

21-year-old male: $2,824

21-year-old male with an accident: $3,981

45-year-old female: $909

65-year-old female: $1,316


  • The company welcomes “high-risk” drivers
  • Flexible payment options
  • Transparent quotes
  • Instant online access
  • SR-22 Filing available


  • Limited discounts
  • The website lacks specific information about coverage
  • No-frills policy

sunset ahead while driving


Geico is the second-largest insurance company in the United States. The company has “excellent” financial strength and scores highly when it comes to customer satisfaction. Geico offers competitive rates, even for individuals with accident records and speeding tickets. 

The insurance provider offers discounts based on your vehicle’s safety features as well as your driving habits. Geico doesn’t use an agent network and depends on centralized call centers and technology to connect with its customers. This company is an excellent choice for new drivers and middle-income families.  

Some auto insurance coverage you can get from Geico include:

  • Collisions
  • Bodily injury liability
  • Emergency roadside services
  • Uninsured motorists
  • Property damage liability

Average Annual Premium

The following premiums are for drivers with a: 

Clean driving record: $2,146

One accident on their record: $3,193

One DUI on their record: $4,876

A speeding violation: $2,645


  • Easy repair process
  • Many standard discounts
  • Innovative mobile app


  • All claims are handled online

State Farm

Founded in 1922, State Farm is one of the leading auto insurance companies in the U.S. today. Besides auto insurance, the company provides several insurance choices such as health, life, home, and a wide selection of other financial services. Moreover, the company is more tolerant of “high-risk”drivers and offers steep discounts.

Some auto insurance discounts offered by State Farm include:

  • Good driving discount
  • Accident-free discount
  • Vehicle safety discount
  • Anti-theft device installation discount
  • Driver safety course discount

In 2019, the company earned a three-star rating in J.D. Power’s Auto Claims Satisfaction Study. With this, it was rated the best auto insurance company in New York and the Mid-Atlantic region. Whether you’ve been convicted of a DWI or have multiple speeding tickets, State Farm can cover you. 

Average Annual Premium

The following premiums are for drivers with a: 

Clean driving record: $2,821

One accident on their record: $3,296

One DUI on their record: $3,637

A speeding violation: $3,186


  • Several discount plans
  • Wide variety of insurance policies
  • Available nationwide
  • High claims satisfaction rating


  • Few coverage options
  • No senior or military discounts

Hand holding phone while driving

Amica Mutual

Amica Mutual is a high-risk auto insurance company that is popular for its customer support rating. The company was ranked as the best in the New England region according to the J.D. Power’s 2020 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. The company is among the top five cheapest auto insurance providers with annual premiums of about $1,500.

Here are some coverages offered by the company:

  • Personal injury protection
  • Underinsured motorist
  • Glass coverage
  • Roadside assistance coverage

Average Annual Premium

The following premiums are for drivers with: 

Reckless driving: $2,761

One DUI: $3,356

A speeding violation: $1,390


  • A low number of customer complaints
  • Many discounts and policies
  • There is a potential of earning dividends


  • Few local offices
  • Not available in some states
  • No military or senior discounts


Unlike other insurance companies, Progressive provides customers with the most control regarding the amount of premium they pay.

Another benefit to working with the company is its simplicity. When setting up your profile, customers only have to provide the necessary information. This includes the vehicle model, address, and whether you lease or own the car. You’ll then be required to state the amount of money you want to spend.

The Progressive site is easy to use, making the process of reporting claims simple. Some unique features of Progressive Insurance include:

  • Roadside assistance
  • Pet injury protection
  • Snapshot
  • Rideshare insurance

Average Annual Premium

The following premiums are for drivers with a: 

Clean driving Record: $3,393

One accident: $4,777

A DUI: $3,970

A speeding violation: $4,002


  • The third-largest auto insurance company


  • High customer complaint

A young man sits with the door open inside of a black used car that’s outdoors.

Look Towards ONIT Home For Easy Insurance Options

ONIT Home provides customers with a wide variety of home & auto insurance options. We work with the top insurance companies to help you get some of the best insurance deals at the lowest price. Our team of licensed brokers specialize in simplifying the insurance shopping journey so you can get the coverage you want, when you need it. Learn more about how you can access the best insurance options by requesting a free quote for home and auto insurance.

Want to learn more about high-risk auto insurance? ONIT Insurance Group can help you find the best coverage for your property. Get in touch with us at 800-610-2146.

Spread the love